I first thought “Great, this is the same idea as Species“. I was pleasantly surprised when it turned out to be different.
Unfortunately I was let down when the movie turned out to be mediocre and didn’t realize its full potential. The premise is that two scientists, Clive and Elsa,(a somewhat dysfunctional married couple played by Sarah Polley and Adrian Brody) break some rules and create a chimera made up of various animals and human DNA. They have to raise this thing in secret while dealing with the research that is required of them by their bosses and the people funding their project.
This is all great fodder for a really interesting science fiction film. Many questions are raised such as:
Should we create such a creature? How much humanity does a strange cross breed like that truly have, even if it behaves in a human fashion? Can this slightly dysfunctional couple learn to be parents to this odd creature?
Some of these questions are answered and the way they are handled brings about some creepy and unexpected scenes. The unfortunate part is that the film dwells on the unnecessary, such as bombarding us with scientific jargon in the beginning only to give us very little information on what went into the creature’s DNA. We get some information about Elsa’s troubled past, but it’s only there to explain her behavior in one odd scene. We also get a lot of odd creature transformations that take this from science fiction and into fantasy land.
This film can’t seem to decide if it wants to give us a philosophical look at scientists playing God and the humanity of their resulting scientific work, whether a dysfunctional couple can learn to parent something that is not entirely human or whether it’s an action horror movie.
Two and half stars **1/2 – Mostly for having an interesting concept that was not executed very well.
Director – Vincenzo Natali